Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

35 Comments

    1. I just use boiled tap water. Distilled water would be great but will increase the cost a little bit. The tap water has worked well for us. Great question…Thanks for writing!!!

      1. Mine has never separated. It actually seem to congeal more and sets up but all that needs to be done is to simply stir to bring the liquid hand soap back to the proper consistency. Thanks for writing!

    1. Make sure to stir your mixture so it becomes more liquid-like. The goal is to have the mixture thick enough so it pumps properly. After stirring, put a little into your pump dispenser with a funnel to make sure it will pump out. The consistency is interesting, we have 2 different types of pump dispensers and it works well in both. But, if yours does not pump out properly, add just a little bit of water and mix well. You do not want it to be too thin. Did you use the Kirk’s Coco Castille Soap? I have not tried any other type of soap so I am not sure how something else would work. I would think it would be okay but please let me know how it goes! Thanks for writing!

      1. I like this idea..it will help me a lot instead of buying expensive hand soap in groscery store. Thank you for the engredients.

        1. Hi Eliza…..yes, me too! I am still amazed that this hand soap recipe makes an entire 1/2 gallon. Sometimes it takes up to 18+ hours to set up so don’t give up! Thanks for writing!

  1. Have seen this few years ago, but with hectic life at the time never got around-to-it. Will do doing it now.

    1. Great! This is a quick and easy recipe…..grate the bar of soap, add to boiling water to melt. Let sit for 24 hours or more. And, it is ready to go! Hope you find the time to make it….Thanks for writing!

    1. I have only used Kirk’s Coco Soap…..but, yes, I would wait longer and I am sure it will all the sudden start to gel. It will almost thicken completely but will come back to a pour liquid with stirring. If you store the extra in a jar, make sure to mix it up a bit before pouring into your soap dispenser. Let me know how it turns out…Thanks for writing!

  2. Hi! Thank you for sharing this! I am at the 60 hour mark and still waiting for the soap to congeal. Have you ever had to wait this long? I used spring water and a homemade coconut/olive oil soap. Maybe it’s not congealing because my soap had natural colorants/essential oils? Thanks in advance for your input 🙂

    1. Hi Beth….I have only used the Kirk’s Coco Castile bar soap for this recipe so I am not sure. The spring water is perfect, I just have not tried any other soaps. You might try a small test batch, using your uncongealed mixture instead of water and Kirk’s Coco Castille soap. Maybe 1 quart of the mixture and 1/4 bar of Kirk’s grated soap to see if you can salvage your first batch. Let me know how it goes!!! Thanks for writing.

    2. Did this ever congeal? I’m using a home made bar of canolive II (Coconut, Olive and canola) and after 12hrs had no congeal, was impatient (I know, I know), and added another 4oz bar (hadn’t read enough maybe?) and waited another 12hrs…nothing, waited until 20hrs and checked with a wooden spoon and still watery. Not sure what gives but I’ll wait longer for now…starting to wonder though.

      1. As I have only used the Kirk’s Original Coco Castile bar soap for this recipe, I am not sure how your homemade coconut canolive bar will work. Give the recipe another try with Kirk’s Castile bar soap to see how it sets up and then in the meantime your other batch may congeal. Thanks for writing.

      2. Did yours ever work with your homemade bar? Still waiting for mine to set (so far at 22 hours) using one of my homemade bars (olive, coconut, palm, and sunflower oils). I know it is still “early” but wasn’t sure what I should should be seeing by this point.

        1. I have only made this liquid hand soap with the Kirk’s Coco Castille Bar Soap….I am interested to see what others are finding with their homemade soap. Keep us posted! Thanks for writing.

    1. I have not needed a preservative as this liquid hand soap seems to keep real well. After filling my pump dispensers, I simply store the rest in a quart size canning jar under the bathroom sink. So far, so good ☺ Thanks for writing!

  3. Oh My…..This is a great blog, I am happy that I have come across this one. It’s an amazing blog to read about diy handmade liquid hand soap. Thanks for this wonderful content. I loved reading your article, will definitely give it a try to store as per your advice. Great blog to share!!

  4. Thank you for the recipe, tried it last week the only issue is it doesn’t lather. It smells great and works great but I would expect it to lather a bit. Did I do something wrong!

    1. I think you did everything right. This recipe just does not create lather. But, like you said, this hand soap works well and smells great!

    1. I usually just leave the lid off but you may put the lid on after the mixture cools. I think putting the lid on too early will cause excess condensation to form. But, having the lid on will protect from anything falling into your Soap Mix!

  5. Great recipe. Would to add a preserative to this recipe if you were going to sell it? If so what kind and how much?

    1. I have just made one batch at a time so I am not a good resource about adding any type of preservative. Please let me know if you find something that works well. Thanks!

  6. Used the soap that you recommended, but it hasn’t congealed. I’m at hour 29 and I have tried stirring it but nothing happens except getting a little foamy. It does not have the milky color like your’s. Just a clear color. I guess I’ll use it and see how it does. I have made homemade laundry soap with bar soap and that congealed. I was expecting this to be the same consistency.

    1. I am not sure why it has not congealed nor why it is clear instead of a milky color. You might simply pour the solution in a jar and set it aside for a week or so to see if it will congeal. Like you mentioned, I would definitely give it try to see how it works as is. Please let us know what happens. Thanks for writing.

  7. I am a sight-challenged woman who absolutely loooooooooooooooooooooooooooves making stuff from scratch, and I’d like to try making this soap one day! I wonder, would it be possible to boil water with my electric kettle, then pour it into a large metal mixing bowl with the grated soap? Would I be able to mix this with my electric mixer? Or would that ruin the machine? If I can’t mix it with the mixer, would I be able to pour the grated soap into a large metal mixing bowl then mix with a wooden spoon? My kettle can safely boil up to 6 cups of water at a time without spilling over.

    1. Sounds like you have a good plan! Yes, boiling your water in your electric kettle should work just fine. Stirring the grated soap into the hot water with a wooden spoon is actually the best method. This is a fun project…hope you enjoy it!

      1. My provider and I made this soap a couple days ago, using a leftover bar of Cetaphil facial soap that I have. We used a handheld cheese grater to grate the soap into my metal mixing bowl. We then poured boiling water from my electric kettle into the bowl, and stirred the water and the soap flakes, which felt like snow, with a wooden spoon. I actually found a refill bottle that’s suitable for soap, which used to have antibacterial liquid soap in it, and I poured it in all by myself, without makin’ a mess! The downside, however, is that it’s a bit thinner than I expected. I think maybe next time, i’ll try to use a little bit less water. How much water should I use to make the soap like the consistency of jelly? I then poured it into my pump bottle, and I’ve actually got quite a bit left in the big bottle! Isn’t that amaaaaaaaaaaaaaaazing?

        1. Yes, that is amazing! Thanks for your note. I have never tried any other soap than the Kirk’s Castile so it is interesting to know how the Cetaphil turned out. Try a little less water with your next batch. Hopefully, that will help with the consistency. Please let me know what you find out! ☺

  8. I am a sight challenged woman who loooooooooooooooooooooooooooves to make stuff from scratch! My provider, Michelle and I made some liquid soap yesterday, from a bar of Cetaphil Daily Facial Cleanser, and it actually worked! However, the downside is that it’s a bit thinner than I expected. We let it congeal for at least twelve hours. I made it in the afternoon, and I checked it this mornin’ when I woke up, and it was a bit thin. I poured it into a refill bottle that used to be Dial Antibacterial Liquid soap, and it fits in there! I even poured it all by myself, without makin’ a mess! I wonder if I should use a little less water next time. I mean, I want it to be the consistancy of jelly. I boiled 6 cups of water in my electric kettle. I think that was a bit too much. How much water do you think I should use to make soap that feels like jelly?